Is your strategic plan still relevant? Should a non-profit shift from a 5-year plan to a 2–3-year roadmap?

When serving on a nonprofit board or board of education, you know that the world does not stand still. Communities evolve, trustees change, and funding is constantly shifting. Needs and programs that felt essential five years ago are no longer relevant to the community or to the constituents’ needs today. Yet many organizations are still operating with strategic plans, created at a very different moment in time. Shifting away from the five-year model to a more flexible two-to-three-year planning cycle isn’t abandoning long-term thinking; it’s about making sure your strategy stays relevant, actionable and aligned with both your mission and the larger community.

Why Shorter Planning Cycles Make Sense

The five-year model is the norm for most boards. But today these five-year long term strategies can become outdated halfway through their lifecycle. The pace of change can quickly outstrip the assumptions on which long-range plans were based.

Shorter plans offer several advantages:

1.) They are more realistic. The Board can plan based on what is actually known rather than on projections about the future.

2.) They are more adaptable. When conditions shift, the plan can shift too.

3.) They keep the Board more engaged. When volunteers or elected officials see goals being accomplished, they are more likely to stay engaged, potentially reducing burnout.

Signs it may be time torevisit your strategic plan:

The board doesn’t need a crisis, such as a pandemic, to justify revisiting or refreshing its strategic plan. In fact, boards may need to revisit their strategic plans more often than they realize. Here are some telltale signs that a formal revisit should be on your next agenda.

1.) The community’s needs have shifted. If the demographics of the community have changed, the community’s needs may have changed as well.

2.) Funding realities have changed. Grants may come and go, and shifts in donor behavior can make the existing plan less feasible.

3.) Technology or the way a program is delivered has evolved. We all know that the rule for the useful life of technology was five years. Now, with AI, technology can become outdated in six months. Since COVID, organizations may also be able to reach more people through virtual meetings.

4.) Has the current Board completed most of the previous goals or did they barely touch them? It is possible for either scenario to be true, and both may signal a misalignment between the plan and the organization’s actual priorities. Some plans may simply not be actionable. So, what should the next chapter look like?

5.) Is the plan more aspirational than practical? A strategic plan should help the board make decisions, not be pretty packaging on a webpage.

A practical approach to shifting to a 2-3 year model

Most nonprofit boards are made up of dedicated or elected volunteers. These are people who willingly give their time, but they don’t need to wade through a 60-page document full of jargon and irrelevant goals. Rather, the board needs clarity, direction and a roadmap to help guide them in decision-making.

Using a 2-3 year horizon keeps the plan relevant and manageable:

  • Build in annual refreshes. Short board retreats or working sessions each year give the trustees a chance to revisit priorities, celebrate progress and adjust to the shifting landscape.
  • Review progress quarterly. This keeps the strategy alive and on target.
  • Listen to the community intentionally. The plan should reflect the real voices of clients, families, staff and other stakeholders.
  • Keep it simple. The strategic plan should be easy to understand and explain.

Wrapping it all up

Your organization’s strategic plan should be a living document that expresses your mission, not something pulled out of the back of a closet every few years. If your board hasn’t revisited the plan in the last 2-3 years, now is the perfect time to take that fresh look.

A shorter, more adaptable planning cycle helps your organization to stay focused, responsive, and aligned with the evolving needs of your community. And for your volunteer board, it makes strategic planning less overwhelming and much more meaningful.


THIS ARTICLE WAS ALSO FEATURED IN NFP ADVISOR VOL. 34. READ THE ARTICLE AND MUCH MORE RELATED CONTENT HERE!

Susan Stewart

Assistant Controller

Susan Stewart is an accomplished accounting professional with over 20 years of experience in finance and accounting across both public and private sectors. As a member of the Outsource Accounting Team, Susan leverages her deep expertise in GAAP, internal controls, and financial regulations to deliver exceptional results for clients.

 

Susan’s career is distinguished by her commitment to fiscal responsibility and operational excellence. She has provided trusted financial guidance as a trustee on the Board of Directors of the Mid-Island Y JCC and as a two-term elected trustee on the Board of Education for the Plainview–Old Bethpage Central School District. Her leadership in these roles reflects her strong analytical skills and her dedication to effective governance.

Outside of her professional endeavors, she is passionate about giving back to the community and serves as a mentor for the nonprofit No Pet Goes Unfed, Inc.

Get in Touch With Us

Whether you have questions, need support, or want to explore opportunities—our team is just a message away.

Email

info@cerinicpa.com

Phone

(631) 582-1600

Address

3340 Veterans Memorial Hwy
Bohemia, NY 11716